Iowa State Cyclones head coach Hoiberg reacts to a call during their third round NCAA tournament basketball game against Ohio State Buckeyes in Dayton

Why the Letter of Intent is awful: Richard Amardi loses scholarship to Iowa State

Leave a comment

By this point, everyone should know that the NCAA’s National Letter of Intent is the worst contract to sign in all of sports.

The intention is good; the goal of the NLI is to end a player’s recruitment when he decides that he wants to go to a certain school.

But the way that it plays out is weighted entirely in favor of the school. The contract legally binds the player to the school, forcing him to enroll for at least a year unless he wants to have a year of his eligibility taken away. That’s precisely what is happening with Notre Dame signee Eddie Vanderdoes. He signed an NLI with Notre Dame, but has since decided that it would be more important for him to attend school closer to home because of an ill family member.

That doesn’t matter, however, since Notre Dame won’t grant him a release. Vanderdoes is going to be spending a year on the sidelines that will cost him a year of eligibility.

That’s not the worst part of the NLI, though.

The worst part is that the school can cut ties with a player at any time it chooses. In other words, signing an NLI in no way guarantees that the player will have a scholarship waiting for him.

Take, for example, Richard Amardi.

Amardi, a 6-foot-9 forward from Indian Hills CC, signed an NLI with Iowa State back in November. For the last nine months, he’s been locked in to be a Cyclone during the 2013-2014 season. But since Fred Hoiberg was once again active on the transfer market and landed for Marshall guard Deandre Kane late last month, there are now no scholarships available for Amardi.

He’s been released from his NLI by Iowa State.

He will not be a Cyclone unless he feels like paying his own way to go to school there.

To be frank, I don’t have a huge issue with the way that ISU head coach Fred Hoiberg handled this situation. Is it ideal? No, but the bottom line is that Amardi got cut. He has one season of eligibility left, and it makes much more sense for Hoiberg to have Kane on the roster than Amardi, considering that both players have just one year of eligibility remaining. At the end of the day, Kane is a better player than Amardi, and while it’s not the classiest way to handle the situation, Hoiberg is there to win basketball games, not to cater to the last scholarship player on his bench.

The best way for him to win basketball games is to give Amardi’s scholarship to Kane. That may hurt him recruiting down the road, but more people are going to remember a poor record next March than are going to remember Hoiberg yanking a kid’s scholarship this June.

The issue here is that the rule is structured this way in the first place.

The problem is the NLI.

It gives all the power and all the leverage to the schools.

And it’s kids like Amardi that end up getting the worst of it.

Hopefully, he can find a place to play out his final year of eligibility.

You can find Rob on twitter @RobDauster.

Big South moving 2016 conference tournament

Cliff Ellis
AP Photo
Leave a comment

The Big South is moving its 2016 men’s basketball tournament out of Coastal Carolina and a new site will be figured out by November. According to a release from the conference the Big South is using a league bylaw that stipulates that members leaving with less than two years of notice are not eligible to host championships. Coastal Carolina announced this summer that it would be leaving for the Sun Belt as of July 2016, so the Big South wants to find a new location that benefits teams staying in the league.

The Big South men’s and women’s conference tournaments are now also going to be split into two unique events, with the men’s championships being held Thursday-Sunday, March 3-6. The women’s event comes the next week from March 10-13. Bids for both events will come into the league and a new location will be selected in the next few months.

It will be interesting to see if the site of the conference tournament is moved to a campus site or placed at a neutral venue. That type of thing could alter how the NCAA tournament autobid gets played out. With Coastal Carolina coming off of back-to-back NCAA tournament appearances, this obviously changes their approach to the postseason now that they have to leave their city.

Virginia Tech could redshirt sophomore guard

AP Photo
Leave a comment

Virginia Tech is trying to decide what to do with injury sophomore guard Ahmed Hill, who had surgery this summer to deal with a tear in his patella tendon in his left knee.

The 6-foot-5 Hill has still not been released to work out with the team, but he is about a week to 10 days ahead of schedule in his rehab. But the injury is still nagging enough that Hill might not be healthy enough to really contritbute this season. Head coach Buzz Williams is deciding soon whether he wants to redshirt Hill or not.

Hill started a team-high 30 games for the Hokies last season, averaging 8.7 points and 3.7 rebounds per game.

“I don’t have a decision on (Hill),” Williams said to reporters on Monday. “I will make the final decision. I’ll let (him) and his mom be a part of it, but I want to make a decision using the wisdom of doing this for a long period of time. If you let a kid make the decision, they always want to play.

“Right now, I don’t feel comfortable that I would want to play him. It’s just too early to be able to have much more of an answer than that.”

It’s still a rebuilding year for Virginia Tech, but they do get Maryland transfer Seth Allen, who is a talented guard who can score. The Hokies were hoping to have Hill and Allen as complimentary perimeter scorers, but now the plans might have to be altered. Williams went on to say that he would like to make a decision on Hill’s status by Halloween.