The latest on Dez Wells: was Xavier right to expel him?

1 Comment

If you missed the post earlier, no criminal charges have been filed against former Xavier forward Dezmine Wells, but that doesn’t mean that this is the end of the controversy.

After the ruling, Hamilton County prosecutor Joe Deters laced into the University for the way that they handled the case, calling the system “fundamentally unfair” and “seriously flawed”.

“It’s up to that private institution,” he said on a radio interview with 700 WLW, “I just believe that in this particular case, we would never take anything to court. It just wouldn’t happen.”

Xavier responded to Deters’ comments with a statement of their own … :

Federal law (Title IX) and federal regulations and guidances prohibit universities from ceding student conduct matters to the criminal justice system. The federal law requires schools to act quickly and all schools, by law, must use the “preponderance of the evidence” standard, whereas the criminal justice system uses the “probable cause” standard to indict, and the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard to convict.

The process used by the Xavier University Conduct Board is the standard used in American universities. The  conduct board heard evidence that may or may not have been heard by the Grand Jury. After the conduct board reached its decision, the matter was considered and upheld by an appeal board of members of the student body, faculty and staff and is final.

… which Wells’ defense attorney, Merlyn Shiverdecker, called “self-serving gobbledygook.”

“I think they were committed to the process and not the fairness of the outcome. Dez Wells got thrown under a bus because of their commitment to the process,” Shiverdecker told ESPN.com. Wells is considering legal action against the University.

But what no one is mentioning here is that Xavier may have had their hands tied. You see, federal investigators have been looking into whether or not Xavier broke Title IX anti-discrimination laws when dealing with sexual assault allegations in recent years. When you combine the very first line of Xavier’s statement with this tweet from Jeff Goodman, who said the incident that resulted in Wells’ expulsion was sexual in nature, and, well, I’ll let you reach your own conclusions.

Wells will not be returning to Xavier. It appears that he will be visiting Louisville and Memphis, according to both Dave Telep and Jon Rothstein, and possibly Texas and Maryland as well. It’s probably worth noting that Wells’ high school coach, Kevin Keatts, is an assistant at Louisville, as well as Kareem Richardson, who coached at Xavier last season. Louisville technically doesn’t have a roster spot available for Wells, but that hasn’t been an issue for the program of late.

Rob Dauster is the editor of the college basketball website Ballin’ is a Habit. You can find him on twitter @robdauster.

Kennesaw State blows eight-point lead in 16 seconds, loses to Elon

Elon Athletics
Leave a comment

Kennesaw State entered Monday night at 1-6 on the season, but with 19 seconds left, it looked like the Owls have their second of the season locked up. Kendrick Ray made a pair of free throws with 19 seconds left to put KSU up 89-81, and all they had to do was avoid a complete meltdown to get out with a win.

They couldn’t.

A Luke Eddy layup with 16 seconds left cut the lead to six, and after KSU’s Nigel Pruitt missed two free throws, Dainan Swoope his a three with seven seconds left to make the score 89-86.

On the ensuing inbounds, Kennesaw State threw the ball away … and then proceeded to foul Eddy when he was shooting a three. This is what that disaster looked like:

Eddy would hit all three threes before, shockingly, KSU turned the ball over again. Elon could not capitalize this time, sending the game to overtime, where the Phoenix outscored the Owls 14-4.

Elon won 104-94.

Here’s what the comeback looked like on the play-by-play:

Screen Shot 2015-12-01 at 7.39.27 AM

Rick Pitino: Louisville ‘just ignored’ in top 25 due of scandal

Rick Pitino
(AP Photo/Timothy D. Easley)
1 Comment

Louisville beatdown Saint Louis at the Barclays Center on Sunday night, a 77-57 win that was much closer at halftime than the final score might indicate.

The win moved the Cardinals to 5-0 on the season, and that, in turn, got Louisville into the back end of both top 25 polls.

They’re 24th in the AP Poll and 22nd in the Coaches Poll, but that happened on Monday morning. On Sunday night, Pitino made sure to get a rant in about how this team is viewed and why pundits and voters should overlook the scandal currently plaguing his program.

“I think people are looking at that and they’re not really studying the team,” he said, according to the Louisville Courier-Journal, adding that he thinks the team is “just ignored” because of the accusations leveled by self-described madam Katina Powell in the book she published back in October.

And here’s the thing: he is 100 percent correct. Louisville was overlooked in the preseason because the scandal, when combined with the fact that the Cardinals are integrating so many new pieces into their rotation, made it tough to see how they would be able to compete at a level that we’ve come to expect out of Louisville teams.

I know that because it’s why my colleagues at NBCSports.com, against my wishes, refused to allow me to rank Louisville in the preseason top 25. In other words, I’ve had first-hand interactions with the haters. But if we’re going to be honest here, scandal or no scandal, Louisville probably wasn’t going to find their way into the preseason top 25, not when they had to replace Terry Rozier and Montrezl Harrell.

And scandal or no scandal, no team from outside the top 25 is going to play their way into the top 25 by beating the likes of North Florida and St. Francis (NY) without some shenanigans — like Fred VanVleet getting hurt, like Indiana collapsing, like Arizona and Cal and Notre Dame playing their way out of the top 20 — happening around the country.

So Pitino is right: the scandal probably did have an impact on how his team was viewed in the preseason.

But Pitino the scandal isn’t what kept them out of the top 25 until Monday.

That weak non-conference schedule and roster turnover was why.

And if we’re going to be honest here, it probably should have kept them out for another week.